Muskegon took a 2-0 lead at halftime, with goals from Jesus Padilla (assist by Carlos Hernandez-Sias) and Angelo Hernandez-Sias (assist by Padilla).
Orchard View rallied late in the game with goals by Caleb Rodriguez and Steven Malecki (assist by Evan McMiller).
Shots on goal were even at six apiece. Muskegon goalkeeper Micah Crocker and Orchard View goalkeeper Dylan Goetz each stopped four shots.
Orchard View, which won three games in a tournament on Saturday in Kalamazoo, is now 3-0-1 on the season. Muskegon is 0-0-1.