North Muskegon found the back of the net only one minute into the game but were unable to hold on to their lead very long.
Reeths-Puffer tied it up in the first half with a goal from Dylon Art who was assisted by Matt Udell.
After a tied 1-1 halftime score, Reeths-Puffer got the only goal of the second half off the foot of Noah Sornwho was assisted by Max Prince.
Brody Yarian made five saves for the Rockets on Thursday, while Reeths-Puffer outshot North Muskegon 14-6.
Reeths-Puffer is now 3-3 on the season and will next host Grand Rapids Union on Tuesday.