The teams traded goals in the first period, with Grand Haven drawing first blood with a goal by Kyle Eveland (assist Brandon Beeler), and Mattawa answering late in the period with a tally from Jake Kruzich.
Mattawan’s Sam Puzevic scored the lone goal of the second period.
Mattawan was on the verge of a one-goal win when Fox scored the late goal for Grand Haven, with assists from Trevor Kalis and TJ Cunningham.
The overtime period was scoreless.
The Buccaneers are now 0-1-1 on the season.