The Lakers fell in three sets (23-25, 14-25, 14-25).
Ella Andree and Kalli Lewkowski led the production with eight digs and five kills apiece.
Avery Britt threw in eight assists and two aces, while Anna Fumarolo added five kills.
Brooklyn Bolthouse also contributed with 11 digs and an ace.
Spring Lake will continue conference play at Coopersville on Tuesday.