The Trojans fought but fell short in three sets (25-17, 25-19, 25-15).
Sadie Haase led the production with seven kills and two blocks.
Auebre Johnson chipped in six kills and a block, while Gracelynn Olson added 19 assists, two aces and two blocks.
Lauren Reidel and Kayla Kolberg were the defensive leaders with 14 digs and 13 digs respectively.
Fruitport will travel to Whitehall on Thursday for a quad-match.