The Rockets started strong, but couldn’t carry the momentum and lost in four sets, 25-21, 18-25, 16-25, 16-25.
Madison Dykema had eight kills with two blocks and Allison McManus had 10 digs and five kills.
Sophia Hekkema chipped in with seven kills and six digs, while Sophia Corradin added six digs and three kills.
Lauren Nelson and Meg Barnes each had seven digs.
Reeths-Puffer (14-19-2) will visit Whitehall on Thursday for a tri-match.