The Lakers lost in four close sets (25-18, 20-25, 20-25, 19-25).
Kalli Lewkowski led with 12 kills and three blocks. Ella Andree threw in 18 digs and eight kills.
Anna Fumarolo made 12 kills with three blocks, while Brooke Bolthouse had 19 digs and Avery Britt made 16 assists.
Spring Lake (20-14, 1-8) is set to host rival Fruitport on Tuesday (Oct. 25).