The Jacks fell behind early with a 2-0 deficit after the first period, but looked like they were putting together a rebound in the second.
Muskegon scored a pair of goals from Joey Larson and Owen Mehlenbacher to tie the score, 2-2 midway through the second period.
Team USA responded with a pair of goals and Muskegon was again down by two, 4-2.
Jacob Guevin added a third goal to close the second period, down by a 4-3 margin.
But the visitors’ fire power was too much as Team USA scored four third-period goals to the Lumberjacks’ lone goal from Larson.
Larson led Muskegon on the night, earning four points with his two goals while adding a pair of assists.
Muskegon is now 25-17-3-3, and in third place behind second-place Chicago and first-place Dubuque.
The Lumberjacks will have a solid opportunity in the conference race when first-place Dubuque comes to town on Friday and Saturday.
Check out photos from the action shot by Sondra Workman.